Come to the MACH Side: Industry leaders talk Composable Commerce.WATCH NOW

Back to blog

Choosing the Right Payment Gateway for Your Ecommerce Store

Bold Commerce Image
Nishit Rajput

Product Marketing Manager

Published on:

In the dynamic world of ecommerce, a seamless payment process is a crucial element of your online store's success. Selecting the right payment gateway can significantly impact your customer experience, conversion rates, and overall business growth.

Let’s delve into the key factors to consider when choosing a payment gateway for your ecommerce platform. Below we’ll highlight the benefits of diversification, and insights into managing the complexity of multiple payment gateways.

Factors to Consider When Selecting a Payment Gateway

When it comes to running an online business, selecting the right payment gateway is crucial. A payment gateway is a service that authorizes credit card payments and enables secure transactions between customers and businesses. With several options available in the market, it is important to consider certain factors before making a decision. Factors such as security, integration options, fees, customer support, and ease of use should all play a role in choosing the best payment gateway for your business.

1. Security:Security is paramount in ecommerce payments. The global payment security market was valued at USD 23.13 billion in 2022 and is expected to grow at a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 13.9% from 2023 to 2030. It is important to look for a payment gateway that employs advanced encryption and fraud prevention measures to safeguard sensitive customer information, and ensure that the chosen gateway is PCI DSS compliant to minimize the risk of data breaches.

A breach in data security not only damages customer trust but can also lead to legal liabilities and financial losses. By prioritizing a payment gateway with robust security features, you safeguard your business's reputation and ensure a secure environment for every transaction.

2. Fees and Pricing Structure: Payment gateway fees can impact your profit margins. Analyze the fee structure, including transaction fees, monthly charges, and any additional costs. Compare various gateways to find one that aligns with your business's financial goals. While 7% of gateways exhibit evidence of implementing gateway setup fees in certain scenarios, a noteworthy trend emerges with 55% of gateways imposing monthly charges. Although a marginal decline is observed in one-time setup fees compared to 2021, there is a slight uptick in monthly gateway fees, with 29% and 51% of gateways being identified for these respective charges.

To identify the most economical option for your enterprise, you must take into account both the quantity and the worth of your transactions.

3. Integration Options: Seamless integration with your chosen ecommerce platform, such as Magento, is crucial for a smooth end-to-end commerce experience. Ensure that the payment gateway offers easy integration capabilities, allowing you to optimize your checkout process and provide a consistent user experience.

A disjointed or cumbersome checkout process can deter potential customers from completing purchases. 18% of shoppers have abandoned their purchase due to a complicated checkout process. By selecting a payment gateway that aligns seamlessly with your ecommerce platform, you eliminate unnecessary hurdles, enhance user experience, and boost the likelihood of successful conversions.

4. Customer Experience:A clunky or confusing checkout process can lead to cart abandonment. Choose a payment gateway that offers a user-friendly interface, supports mobile responsiveness, and enables quick and secure transactions. A positive customer experience can boost conversion rates and customer loyalty.  A striking 38.4% expressed their willingness to switch payment channels or methods to expedite transaction processing. Furthermore, frustrations over prolonged bill payment processing times have escalated, with 29.6% voicing dissatisfaction.

Downtime or technical issues during the payment process can lead to frustration and lost sales. A payment gateway that provides reliable support and maintains a high level of uptime contributes to a seamless shopping experience and customer satisfaction.

5. Mobile Payment Support:With the rise of mobile commerce, having mobile payment support is essential. Choose a payment gateway that offers seamless mobile payment options and ensures a frictionless checkout experience for customers using smartphones and tablets.  Research suggests a remarkable surge in mobile wallet usage has been recorded, with 43.1% of respondents reporting reliance on mobile wallets for payments.

With the exponential rise in mobile shopping, a mobile-optimized payment gateway is no longer a luxury—it's a necessity. By embracing mobile payment optimization, you tap into a significant market segment and position your online store for success in the mobile era.

At the forefront of this transformative journey is Bold’s Payment Booster — designed to amplify your payment gateway strategy and take your ecommerce venture to unprecedented heights. As you navigate the intricacies of modern online commerce, Payment Booster emerges as the quintessential tool to fortify your payment infrastructure.

Diversification: The Power of Multiple Payment Gateways

Providing a seamless and flexible payment experience is paramount in the world of ecommerce payments. In this pursuit, the strategic integration of multiple payment gateways emerges as a potent catalyst for elevating your online store's performance. On average a website utilizes 3-4 payment gateway options to offer a wide-range of flexibility to customers.

1. Catering to Diverse Customer Preferences:Every customer is unique, and their preferred payment method may vary. By offering a range of payment gateways, you empower customers to choose the option that aligns with their comfort and convenience. A nearly 5% rise in consumer preference for alternative payment methods such as Venmo, Apple Pay, and PayPal for bill payments underscores the evolving landscape of payment options.

Some might prefer credit cards, while others might lean towards digital wallets or PayPal. Providing these choices increases the likelihood of completed purchases and boosts overall customer satisfaction.

2. Global Reach and Localization:The ecommerce landscape knows no boundaries. Having multiple payment gateways enables you to cater to international customers by offering localized payment methods.According to TSG’s research 43% of gateways are considered to have global reach or have stated functionality and client base on at least two continents.

Different regions have distinct payment preferences, and embracing diverse gateways allows you to seamlessly tap into new markets and provide a familiar checkout experience.

3. Mitigating Risk and Enhancing Reliability:Relying solely on a single payment gateway can expose your business to potential risks. Technical glitches, downtime, or disruptions can occur. According to Baymard, 14% shoppers do not complete their purchase due to website errors or crashes. By diversifying your options, you create a safety net, ensuring that if one gateway encounters issues, transactions can still proceed through alternative channels. This risk mitigation enhances the reliability of your payment process, fostering customer trust.

4. Optimizing Conversion Rates:A streamlined and convenient payment process is a conversion catalyst. An average large-sized ecommerce site can gain a 35.26% increase in conversion rate though better checkout design. Customers who encounter payment difficulties or lack their preferred payment method might abandon their carts. By offering multiple gateways, you minimize friction during checkout, reducing cart abandonment rates, and optimizing your conversion rates.

5. Elevating Trust and Credibility:Offering a variety of well-known and trusted payment gateways enhances your store's credibility. According to a study conducted by Baymard University, 17% of shoppers opt to abandon their purchases due to concerns about the security of utilizing their credit card on the respective website. Customers are more likely to trust a business that provides familiar and reputable payment options, contributing to a positive brand image and long-term customer relationships.

Managing Payment Complexity

Managing payment complexity can be a challenging task for businesses. With the increasing variety of payment methods available, such as credit cards, mobile payments, and digital wallets, businesses must ensure that they can accommodate and process these different payment options. Additionally, businesses also need to navigate the complexities of payment regulations and security measures. This requires careful planning and implementation of payment systems that can handle the complexity while also providing a seamless and secure experience for customers.

1. Prioritize Integration: Choose payment gateways that integrate well with your ecommerce platform. APIs and plugins can streamline the integration process and reduce potential complications.

2. Clear Communication:Ensure your customers are aware of the payment options available. Clearly display accepted payment methods during the checkout process to avoid confusion.

3. Analytics and Reporting:Leverage analytics tools to track payment performance. This data can help you identify which gateways are driving conversions and optimize your strategy accordingly.

4. Streamlined Customer Support:Train your customer support team to handle inquiries related to various payment gateways. Providing prompt and accurate assistance can enhance customer satisfaction.

5.Prioritize the most popular payment methods: Identify the most popular payment methods used by your target audience and prioritize integrating with those providers first. This reduces the complexity of managing multiple integrations and focuses on the payment methods that are most relevant to your customers.

Redefine ecommerce payments with Payment Booster

In the complex landscape of ecommerce payments, the strategic significance of having more than one payment gateway cannot be overstated. By offering customers a choice of payment methods, you enhance their experience, expand your global reach, and mitigate risks. While managing multiple gateways may present challenges, you can navigate the complexities and create a seamless payment process that drives your e˙commerce success.

Payment Booster stands as a beacon of transformation, addressing the complexities of multiple payment gateways and paving the way for a seamless, customer-centric payment process. With Payment Booster in your arsenal, you're not just managing payments – you're revolutionizing the way your online store engages with customers, drives conversions, and conquers new horizons. Embrace the power of Payment Booster and redefine your ecommerce success story today.Remember, a well-chosen and well-managed payment gateway is a key ingredient in your recipe for ecommerce triumph.

See tailored checkout in action

Get the knowledge and inspiration you need to grow your business.

Bold Commerce needs your email to send newsletters. For more information, read our Privacy Statement.

About the author
Bold Commerce Image

Nishit Rajput

Product Marketing Manager

Nishit Rajput is a Product Marketing Manager at Bold Commerce

One-size-fits-all checkout is dead. It pays to be Bold.

See tailored checkout in action