Frequently Asked Questions About Bold Memberships & Loyalty Rewards (FAQ)
Bold's Memberships and Loyalty Rewards App is an all-in-one tool built for Shopify that enables features most merchants have to install three separate apps to acquire. Yes. You read that correctly. Memberships is capable of running both free and paid membership tiers, a loyalty and store-credit program, and control access to products, content and checkout, and it carries the whole thing into physical retail through Shopify POS. Members earn store credit, points and perks, redeem them online and at the register, and carry a loyalty card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. To make choosing an app a little easier, and to show how Bold Memberships holds up against loyalty apps, members-only apps and B2B gating apps alike. Here are the questions merchants ask us most.
What's a membership app?
Membership apps let store owners reward loyal shoppers, charge for access, or both. Some focus on perks and points. Others focus on gating, which means showing or hiding products, pricing and content by membership status. The strongest ones combine the two, so a retailer can run a rewards program and a members-only storefront from the same place instead of paying for two tools that never quite talk to each other.
What's the difference between a membership program and a loyalty points app?
Loyalty points reward past behavior with a currency the shopper redeems later. Membership creates an ongoing relationship instead. It brings recurring revenue, exclusive access, and automated perks that apply at every transaction without the friction of remembering to redeem a code. Points look backward at what a customer already did. Membership looks forward at what keeps bringing them back.
What's Bold Memberships and Loyalty Rewards?
Bold Memberships and Loyalty Rewards is a Shopify app that runs a full retention program from one dashboard. It handles free and paid membership tiers, recurring billing and free trials, a loyalty program of points, store credit and member discounts, and access control over products, collections, content and checkout. It sells and redeems memberships in-store through Shopify POS (The Point of Sale software that allows merchants to sell their products in person in physical retail stores, popups, and other "brick and mortar" locations), issues Apple and Google Wallet cards, and reads member tags from other apps through Universal Tagging. Setup takes no developer and no custom code, and the app first launched in 2017 before its June 2026 redesign-rebuild.
How many membership structures does the app support?
Four, and most successful programs mix more than one. A free tier builds repeat-purchase habit and lifetime value before you ask for a dollar. A paid tier turns loyalty into recurring, high-margin revenue. A subscription add-on reads your existing subscriber tags and layers membership perks on top to cut subscription churn. And a B2B tier gates wholesale pricing and catalogues behind approved trade accounts. You can run any of these on their own or combine them in one program.
Can I run free community tiers alongside paid memberships?
Yes. Mix free and paid tiers in the same program. Use the free tier to grow your audience fast, then convert engaged members into paid tiers with premium perks. Free members usually convert at a much higher rate than a cold audience, so the free tier doubles as your best paid-conversion funnel.
How do customers join a membership?
Three ways. Open enrollment lets any shopper join automatically on account creation, first purchase, or a click, which grows a member base quickly. Rule-based enrollment qualifies customers automatically when they hit criteria you set, such as a spend threshold, an order count, a product purchase or a tag, so membership feels earned. Manual approval suits trade accounts, where you admit each buyer yourself. Membership rules re-evaluate on their own as customers qualify or lapse.
Can I offer a free trial on a paid membership?
Yes. You can add a free trial period to a paid tier, and 14 or 30 days is usually the sweet spot. Members who experience the perks before committing convert at meaningfully higher rates than those asked to pay up front. The app itself also starts with 30 days free.
How does automated store credit work?
Store credit drops to members automatically on a schedule you set, and it applies at checkout on their next order. Because it arrives on a cycle, it gives paid members a standing reason to return before it expires. Pair a credit drop with a lock-screen push notification and a member wakes up to store credit waiting, which reads as a purchase occasion rather than another email.
Can members use their points, credit and perks in my physical store?
Yes. Bold Memberships integrates natively with Shopify POS, so member pricing, store credit and tier perks apply at the register exactly as they do online. Members can buy a membership in-store and redeem one in-store, and the Apple or Google Wallet card makes recognition at the counter as fast as a scan. This omnichannel reach is the piece most browser-only loyalty apps cannot match.
Do I need a developer to gate content or products?
No. Bold Memberships uses customer tags and Liquid-based logic to show or hide content, pricing and buttons by membership tier, and all of it is configured through the dashboard. It works in modern Shopify themes without custom code, so a store owner sets up gating without hiring anyone.
What can I gate behind a membership?
Pages, individual products, whole collections, blog articles, how-to videos, drip content, add-to-cart buttons, hidden pricing and the checkout itself, each assigned to the membership tiers you choose. The point is not only to keep non-members out. It is to give your best customers a world of their own while everyone else sees the standard storefront.
Can I hide pricing from non-members?
Yes. Pricing can stay hidden until a shopper signs in or qualifies, set site-wide, by collection, by product or by tier. Hidden pricing is a favorite of B2B and trade programs, where retail prices show publicly while wholesale rates appear only to approved members, and it works in DTC too, where a hidden price makes a non-member aware they are missing something before they even know what it is.
Can I gate specific collections or my whole catalogue?
Both. Gating rules apply at the product level, the collection level or across the whole storefront, and rules layer, so a base tier can see a subset of collections while higher tiers see everything.
Does the app hide members-only products from non-members entirely?
Members-only products and collections display only to qualifying members and stay hidden from everyone else, gated by tier through customer tags and Liquid logic.
What happens if a customer cancels their paid membership?
Recurring billing stops at cancellation, and you control how a lapsed member is handled from there on a schedule you set, including whether they keep any accrued store credit for a window. The same automatic rule evaluation that grants membership when a customer qualifies also manages the exit when they no longer do.
Does Bold Memberships work with my other apps?
Yes, and this is one of its stronger cards. Universal Tagging lets Bold read member tags set by any other app in your stack, from loyalty platforms to review tools to subscription apps, so Bold becomes the hub that applies member benefits rather than another disconnected silo. It is also how the subscription add-on works, by reading your existing subscriber tags without a second sign-up.
Can I automate member journeys?
Yes. Bold Memberships is fully compatible with Shopify Flows, so you can automate welcome emails, tier-upgrade triggers, monthly store-credit drops, win-back flows for members who have gone quiet, and anniversary or milestone rewards. Set these up on day one and the program runs itself.
Does the app work for international stores?
Yes. Bold Memberships offers multilingual support and full Shopify Markets compatibility for eight languages (English, French, German, Spanish, Italian, Dutch, Portuguese and Japanese) and counting. So language, currency and regional pricing are handled, and a member program works as well in Bordeaux, Bologna or Berlin as it does in Bungo-Ōno, Braga, Barcelona or Boston.
Can I set different member prices on different products?
Yes, through the Bold Custom Pricing integration. Together the two apps set different prices for different members on different products, product by product and variant by variant, by CSV upload or manual entry. That protects margin on your best sellers and vendor-restricted SKUs instead of applying one blanket member discount across the catalogue. Both apps must be installed.
How does Bold Memberships compare to loyalty-first apps like Smile and LoyaltyLion?
Smile and LoyaltyLion focus on loyalty points as a standalone offering. Bold Memberships and Loyalty Rewards combines loyalty points with paid membership tiers, so a store owner can charge for premium rewards and earn recurring revenue while running the points program itself. It also handles POS transactions, Apple and Google Wallet cards, and multilingual stores natively rather than as paid add-ons.
| Feature | Bold Memberships & Loyalty Rewards | Smile.io | LoyaltyLion | Yotpo Loyalty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loyalty points program | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Recurring store credit | Yes | Limited | Limited | No |
| Cashback-style store credit | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| Free shipping for members | Yes, native | Higher tier only | Higher tier only | Higher tier only |
| Percentage and fixed discounts | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Paid membership tiers | Yes | No | No | No |
| Loyalty and memberships in one app | Yes | No | No | No |
| POS integration | Yes, native | Higher tier | Higher tier | Higher tier |
| Apple and Google Wallet passes | Yes | No | No | No |
| Multi-language support | 8 languages | Limited | Limited | Yes |
| Recurring member revenue | Yes | No | No | No |
| Pricing model | First 10 members free, then $0.13/member/month | Free to $999/mo | $199 to $700/mo | $199+/mo |
How does Bold Memberships compare to members-only and content-gating apps like Conjured, Simplee and Locksmith?
Locksmith is a locking utility that hides pages based on conditions. Bold Memberships & Loyalty Rewards ties gated content to a membership program, so a merchant can charge for access, tier the content, and connect the same members to loyalty rewards, POS transactions and wallet cards. Locksmith locks. This app monetizes what is locked.
| Feature | Bold Memberships & Loyalty Rewards | Conjured | Simplee | Locksmith |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Members-only products | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Private collections | Yes | Yes | Limited | Yes |
| Locked articles, blogs and videos | Yes | Limited | Limited | Limited |
| Early access to new drops | Yes | Limited | Limited | No |
| Products hidden from search and sitemap | Yes | Varies | Varies | Yes |
| Enforcement not CSS-only | Yes | Varies | Varies | Yes |
| Paid and free membership tiers | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Loyalty rewards included | Yes | No | Limited | No |
| POS integration | Yes, native | No | No | No |
| Apple and Google Wallet passes | Yes | No | No | No |
| Multi-language support | 8 languages | Limited | Limited | Limited |
How does Bold Memberships compare to gating, wholesale and B2B apps?
Wholesale apps like Locksmith, SparkLayer and Conjured usually focus on price lists, purchase orders and net terms for verified accounts. Bold Memberships & Loyalty Rewards focuses on gating access to commerce itself for any qualifying member group, whether that is B2B buyers, collectors or invite-only DTC, and it pairs with Bold Custom Pricing for SKU-level rates by tier. It works alongside a dedicated wholesale app for merchants who need both.
| Feature | Bold Memberships & Loyalty Rewards | Locksmith | SparkLayer | Conjured |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hide pricing site-wide | Yes | Limited | Limited | Limited |
| Gate add-to-cart | Yes | Yes | Limited | Yes |
| Gate checkout by membership tier | Yes | No | No | Limited |
| Enforced at resource level | Yes | Yes | No | Varies |
| Survives theme updates | Yes | Yes | Yes | Varies |
| Requires Shopify Plus | No | No | No | No |
| Not customer-tag scripting | Yes | Yes | Yes | Varies |
| Membership program included | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Loyalty rewards included | Yes | No | No | No |
| POS integration | Yes, native | No | No | No |
| SKU-level member pricing (with Custom Pricing) | Yes | No | Yes | No |
Can I migrate from another loyalty and rewards or membership app?
Yes. Bold offers free white-glove migration and includes free human setup support, so a real person helps you move your program and get it live rather than leaving you with a self-service import.
Which merchants benefit most from Bold Memberships?
Store owners who want more than one thing from a single install. That includes DTC brands running loyalty or paid VIP tiers, retailers who want one program online and in-store through POS, publishers and creators gating premium content, subscription brands adding a membership layer to cut churn, and wholesale or B2B sellers gating trade pricing and catalogues.
Where can I get help setting up Bold Memberships?
Bold's Help Center offers documentation and guides around the clock, live chat is available inside the app, and every account comes with free setup support from a real person. For merchants moving from another platform, Bold's team handles the migration at no charge.